Tracker Pixel for Entry

‘You were charged, you appeared, and you pled guilty’

by C.S. Hagen | .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address) | News | April 2nd, 2018

Zebadiah Gartner after paying $400 fine for piece of chicken - photograph by C.S. HagenFARGO – Zebadiah Gartner worked with family over the weekend to raise money for a fine and court fees to pay for an extra piece of sample chicken he took from Cashwise Foods in January 2017. Family and community pitched in; proceeds from an Indian Taco event helped Gartner raise the needed $500.

On Monday morning, however, expecting Mayor Tim Mahoney’s weekend plea for leniency in his case to have some effect, Gartner was hoping for a lower fine. Fargo’s Municipal Court Judge Stephen Dawson did throw out the $100 bench warrant fee, and Gartner paid the additional $400 to stave a possible 10-day jail sentence.

The extra piece of chicken was a boneless Buffalo Wing taken from the sample counter at Cashwise Foods, Gartner said. An undercover shopper followed him around the store and approached, telling him customers could only take one piece, he said. Gartner threw the extra piece away, never guessing that the store would file a complaint against him.

Mahoney said over the weekend that Cashwise Foods was not interested in pursuing the matter, but because Gartner’s plea of guilty last year to the theft, the judicial process was already underway. Gartner spent a night in jail after his first arrest on February 23, 2017, and spent a second night in jail because of the bench warrant for failure to pay last week.

Gartner learned about the theft charge after he was arrested during last year’s sweat lodge incident, he said. At the time, Fargo Police stated they were unaware of the spiritual significance of the sweat lodge, and after seeing a fire, and what they perceived to be a tent with homeless people, ordered participants – young and old – and in little more than undergarments or light clothing, into the cold.

Gartner was arrested for resisting police that night, and the charges were dismissed the following day, but not after he spent the night behind bars.

Zebadiah Gartner at Fargo's Municipal Court with paperwork after being order to pay fine of $400 - photograph by C.S. Hagen

Before the judge on Monday morning, Gartner stated that although he pled guilty to theft on iTV court in February, he did not sign the documents.“There’s no proof of me stealing this chicken,” Gartner said. “That was a hard day last year.”

Although he pled guilty on iTV in 2017, Gartner plans on filing a motion to change his guilty plea, he said.

“I didn’t write guilty on the paper,” Gartner said.

“So you appeared from jail on this? Originally?” Dawson said. “You must have been in jail for something unrelated.”

“Yeah, I was arrested for resisting an officer.”

“So, is this your signature?”

“No, sir.”

“That’s not your signature,” Dawson said. “At the jail you would have received some papers: a rights form, a plea form, and a confidential information form… So you are suggesting someone else signed the guilty form?”

Dawson said the signatures appeared to match; Gartner disagreed.

Paperwork showing Zebadiah Gartner's signatures, which he claims he never signed to his guilty verdict - photograph by C.S. Hagen

Gartner, an Anishinaabe, who received the familial ceremonial pipe known as the chanupa after the sweat lodge incident, has been on a spiritual journey ever since the incident. Receiving the chanupa means that he must lead a righteous life, he said.

He is studying Indigenous ways, frequents rallies and marches, and can often be seen singing traditional songs while beating a Native drum. He has been instrumental to Fargo’s only Indigenous sweat lodge ceremonies during the past year; each event takes hours to prepare. There’s wood to cut, red-hot stones to carry, and water to pour. A sweat lodge ceremony can be compared to a Christian going to church.

Before the sentencing, he talked about spiritual occurrences during sweat ceremonies that help keep him growing, and sometimes help heal those who are injured in body or spirit.

Despite having no criminal record, Fargo’s Municipal Court would not lower Gartner’s initial fine, even after a plea from Mahoney for leniency.

“If the city may be heard on this matter,” the prosecutor for the City of Fargo, Stamate Skliris, said. “The city recognizes from the outset that the court is a separate and independent entity, and that it is unusual for the city to weigh in on sentencing matters. Ultimately we recognize that the court is going to make its decision and we respect that, but we’ve heard from a number of witnesses in this case and the nature of this case that the defendant was arrested last year… and subsequently the day after he was charged with shoplifting.”

The city asked for $400 to be paid off over a period of time.

“It’s our understanding at the city that the defendant is unable to pay the fine, and the city does not object the conversion of the $400 and/or the 10 days that was told by the court last Thursday for a jail sentence and run if as a second period of deferred imposition sentence for 11 months,” Skliris said. 

If he could not pay the fine, Gartner could have faced jail time.

“If he couldn’t pay the $400, then it was 10 days,” the prosecutor said.

“A $500 fine would usually equate 10 days in jail,” Judge Dawson said. “The original cost was $400, and there is usually a $100 bench warrant fee, just to keep the deferred intact, and again, you always have the option of reopening the case. If you did not sign this, and you want to straighten her out, you have a signature that certainly appears to be yours, but if you’re indicating it isn’t, then you have those options.”

“I feel there are some other words supposed to be said, but why do I have to pay such a high amount?” Gartner said.

Dawson did not accept the prosecutor’s recommendation or Gartner’s petition to lower the fine.

“You were charged, you appeared, and you pled guilty,” Dawson said. “On the books this is still a deferred imposition sentence.”

“Thankfully I have support from the community,” Gartner said. “That’s the only reason that I have any kind of cash right now.” 

Meme of Zebadiah Gartner with chicken leg - provided by Zebadiah Gartner

Recently in:

BISMARCK – Backed by police and educators, state legislators hope to curb violent crime and rising suicide rates by proposing bipartisan legislation that would allow police to temporarily confiscate firearms from those deemed…

It is no secret that our world is becoming more and more computerized. Over the course of a few decades, computers and the Internet have transformed from being solely objects of luxury or business to a ubiquitous part of 21st…

Wednesday, January 23, at 6-8 p.m.Plains Art Museum, 704 1st Ave. N, FargoMeet featured artists and learn about the Human Rights Arts Festival. The North Dakota Human Rights Arts Festival is a traveling juried exhibition that…

A couple of days before Christmas, a video of “Virgin Island Vicky,” went viral. Her real name is irrelevant, but she’s a Minot native. The video shows her going on multiple public racist rants while she and her beau were on…

The Epic Battle Between Milk And WaterI didn’t realize our neighbor state Wisconsin had over 15,000 lakes until I Googled. Well, it might depend on how you count them according to size and acreage. We know that Minnesota has…

FARGO - A collection of memories from High Plains Reader's annual Cocktail Showdown. Participants were judged on creativity, flavor, and presentation; and this year we added a new category. Like years before, each establishment was…

All About Food

​Curry in a Hurry

by HPR Contributor

By Nataly Routledgenatalyroutledge@googlemail.com My least favorite thing about being a college student is the limited selection of food that I am comfortable making with minimal ingredients and minimal effort. Plus, I liked to try…

Music

To Broadway and back

by HPR Contributor

By Ryan Jankeryan.janke78@gmail.comCelebration of Women and Their Music kicks off this Thursday at the Spirit Room in Fargo, and Nina Grollman will be back in town to light up the stage with a brand-new sound. High Plains Reader…

Compared to the Betsy West and Julie Cohen documentary “RBG,” Mimi Leder’s period biographical slice “On the Basis of Sex” is nowhere near as notorious as one might hope, but the hagiographic reverence for Ruth Bader…

By Nataly Routledgenatalyroutledge@googlemail.com"Snowgeese" for Charles BeckBy Timothy MurphyThe flock is whorled like a translucent shelland intricate as the tubing of a horn,its embouchure, the soft foot of a snaillighting on…

by Ryan Jankeryan.janke78@gmail.comFargo-Moorhead Community Theatre presents “A Christmas Story: The Musical” which is underway at the Stage at Island Park and will run through December 22. It has been promoted as a show both…

Those who have been reading my articles for a while may remember when I interviewed Zachary Tooker about the Level Two Comedy Club at the Radisson in Fargo. While the club may have unfortunately closed, Tooker has not ceased…

by Gabrielle Herschgabbyhersch@gmail.comphotography by Logan MacraeEver wish you could go to your favorite brewery without leaving your house? Finally, you can (sort of). Kilstone Brewing is now doing limited can releases of some…

I’m a big man, I’m tall and powerful, but this also causes some issues in the body department. I suffer from acute scoliosis in my lower back, and pain radiates from this area on a daily basis. I have only ever had one massage…

by Devin Joubertdevinlillianjoubert@gmail.comIt’s that beautiful time of the year that’s filled with seasonal decorations, sparkly lights, warm family gatherings, and delicious feasts. I love everything about this time of the…

By Gary Olsonolsong@moravian.edu"People spend so much time mocking Trump or waiting for him to be impeached. And the danger with this kind of obsession with a single person is that you don’t see the system that produced him."—…