Tracker Pixel for Entry

Ask me to give, not give back

by Rob Port | .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address) | Say Anything | December 25th, 2015

I hate being asked to give something back this time of year.

Before I explain why, let me tell you that what I like best about the holiday season is the focus on charity. There is something wonderful about a time of year when we focus on being thankful for what we have and helping those around us.

Yet there is something irksome in the way we talk about charity. We are inundated with messages telling us to “give back.” Pitch after pitch for charity tells us to “give something back this holiday season.”

Give something, sure. But give something back?

I dislike that phrase “give back.” Not because I’m opposed to charity, but rather because it supposes what we have to give came at the expense of somebody else.

I don’t think the phrase is often used with malice. For most it’s just something you say.

Some do believe that the successful prosper as the expense of others -- Sen. Bernie Sanders is an example -- and that’s wrong-headed thinking.

Those are people who believe economics is a zero sum game. They believe there is only so much wealth to be had, and if one group of people accumulates wealth it means there is less wealth available for others.

From this flows a preference for equal economic outcomes achieved through high-tax, big-government, “eat the rich” policies aimed at redistributing wealth.

But that’s not how the world works. Wealth in the world isn’t static. In fact, wealth is created.

Let me give you an example.

Suppose I have $100,000 and I want to build a new home. I take that $100,000 and spend in on contractors and supplies and all the other things it takes to build a home.

At the end of the building the $100,000 is gone, but I now have a new asset in the form of a new home that is worth (assuming I did it right) more than the $100,000 I invested.

This means a net gain in my personal wealth, but the gain isn’t only mine. The $100,000 I put into building the home went into the pockets of all the contractors and suppliers who helped me build the home. They all benefited too, selling their skills and labor and supplies to me at a profit.

In the process of building a new home, I not only enriched myself but I enriched a wide group of people around me. The same goes for somebody who builds a business. They supply goods and/or services to the public at large and turn a profit for themselves. In doing so, by necessity, they create jobs and commerce for other people and businesses.

I would argue that, short of theft or slavery or other unlawful enterprise, it is impossible for anyone in America to become rich without also creating opportunity and prosperity for others.

This is the beauty of capitalism and free markets, which have done more to lift people around the globe out of poverty than all the charitable work ever done.

Add up all the charitable works by all the churches and social organizations you can think of and their accomplishments will pale in comparison to the good done each day by free people making free choices in a free economic environment in pursuit of their own self interest.

Which brings me back to this whole “give back” thing and the presumption that, by prospering, I’ve somehow taken from society at large and must balance the ledger.

It’s simply wrong. We should stop using the term.

We should not, however, stop supporting charities. They have their place, and they achieve great things.

So please do ask us to give. Just don’t ask us to give back, because every day we spend in pursuit of happiness is a day we also spend creating opportunity for others.

Recently in:

cshagen@hpr1.comBISMARCK - One day after law enforcement cleared the “Treaty Camp” on October 27, 2016, hundreds of activists defending Native American treaty rights, water rights, and land rights, lined up north of three…

Culture

Millennial

by James Osborne

We all know that labels can lead to some unfair and incorrect conclusions. Is it a coincidence that the generation that everyone loves to hate has been given the most faceless and disaffectionate of all the generational labels?…

Friday, June 23, 6pm till lateSidestreet Grill, 404 4th Ave N, FargoThe best way to spend Friday evening, hipping and hopping in Sidestreet’s parking lot with Kipp G, Circle of Heat, and for the first time in several months, D…

Albert Einstein once said, “The revolution introduced me to art, and in turn, art introduced me to the revolution.”This past Sunday marked the 58th year of the Rourke’s Great Midwestern. Though Jim O’Rourke, founder of the…

From Homer’s Odyssey to Buddy Holly: The times they are a-changin’When Robert Zimmerman, born in Duluth and raised in Hibbing, better known as Bob Dylan, won the Nobel Prize for Literature (worth almost a cool $1 million), he…

The moment of truth has arrived. After seven weeks of sampling and judging some of the finest libations in the area the results for this year’s Cocktail Showdown have arrived. Christopher Larson, Raul Gomez and Sabrina Hornung…

On a sultry Thursday night, I sauntered into Luna. Situated on South University next to Bernie’s Beer and Wine, it isn’t exactly a hole in the wall, but it is certainly off the beaten path, and as described by their motto it is…

Pursuing a hobby, much less a career in music is more difficult than just picking up an instrument. Though the passion may be there, the cost of equipment and lessons can be prohibitive.Of course this is something that…

A couple of classic courtroom dramas and a romantic melodrama about theatrical ambition, all adapted from popular novels of their day, are among the recently released Blu-rays by Kino-Lorber. All were made by major filmmakers with…

“I was devastated, scared, and lost. My family’s world changed and our relationships with one another changed too.” said Lonna Whiting.Whiting, co-founder of Brains on the Plains, went on. “In addition to a dramatic shift…

Author, professor, historian and now playwright: Dr. Charlie Barber has taken his love of history to the stage with his new musical, “No Backseat Driver.”Barber’s play is the story of two North Dakota heroes: “Wild Bill”…

Humor

​Talking to strangers

by Sabrina Hornung

“I don’t have a tour, like, on the back of a sweatshirt,” comedian Paula Poundstone says. “I go out every weekend. This weekend I went out Friday, Saturday and Monday. Mostly it’s Friday/Saturday or Thursday through…

Here in the upper midwest we love the summer season for so many different reasons but two of the big reasons I love summer are fresh produce and being outside with a beer in my hand. Sometimes, when I’m spending the day in the…

Wellness

​Natural sleep aids

by Erin Oberlander

As I interact with clients and friends and family alike, one of the issues that comes up commonly is that of sleep. It seems that in our modern world, getting deep, nourishing sleep has become a challenge for some and a complete…

Live and Learn

​The other shoe

by HPR Contributor

By Elizabeth Nawrotnawrot@mnstate.eduI look up from my hotel lobby breakfast astonished to see a framed print of Wassily Kandinsky's "Mit und Gegen,” a masterpiece of color and composition that just happens to be my favorite…

The North Dakota Department of Health has called “Bullsh*t!” on Meridian Energy’s application to construct its Davis Oil Refinery three miles from Theodore Roosevelt National Park.In fact, in a strongly-worded letter to…