Tracker Pixel for Entry

Are We Ready for the Death of Coal?

Culture | November 27th, 2019

Cover design by Raul Gomez

By Waylon Hedegaard
retiringwithcats@gmail.com

I have lived a truly blessed life. I’m married to the best human being on the planet and have a child that fills my heart with pride. But I know what made most this possible was that I was fortunate to stumble into a great union career. Most of my adult life, I’ve worked as a Union Boilermaker in coal-fired power plants. This work fed my family, kept a roof over our heads and allowed us to lead the lives we lead. Even with the reality of climate change, I am still proud of my work.

However, I am not blind to this reality. I love truth far too much to tell myself lies about climate change. I trust science far more than I trust my own desires or needs. Science has saved my soul, and I’m not about to doubt it now.

Climate change is real, and we are causing it. Period. The era of coal-fired power generation is coming to an end. The work I’ve done for decades will be no more.

Oh, coal’s not disappearing tomorrow. Huge sections of the technology to replace it doesn’t exist now at the needed levels. Elements of coal will be with us for a few decades, but we need to face the reality that in five years, there will be significantly fewer coal fired power plants in the US, and in ten years even fewer. Every year more plants will close, and more workers and their families will lose their economic stability.

This is great for the environment but terrible for those who bear the financial burden.

But let me state this plainly. No one can save coal. All the lies and promises in the world can only delay its demise and then only slightly. I have spent half my career talking to my fellow workers about the dangers of ignoring this issue, because many have bought into the lie that climate change is a hoax.

Yet in coal’s demise, it hardly matters whether we believe the science or not. In fact, the reality of climate change itself barely matters either. It’s not going to be new environmental laws that kill coal. It’s not going to be groups like the Sierra Club or Earth First. It’s not going to be subsidies for renewables or carbon taxes or any other “liberal conspiracy”.

The reality is that coal is being slaughtered by capitalism itself. It’s already in the chute.

I am hardly a fan of Neo-liberal Capitalism, yet it is hard to ignore the fact that the strongest forces crushing coal are the inevitable economic forces capitalism brings to bear. The only thing that would save coal would be socialism on the grandest scale.

In that light of coal’s demise, let’s discuss some uncomfortable truths. There are certainly many things that people hate about coal fired power. Nevertheless, there are benefits it has brought to North Dakota like the thousands of highly-skilled, highly-paid jobs. This has raised thousands of us out of potential poverty and allowed us to raise our families in comfort and security. In turn, this has given several North Dakotan communities the opportunity to thrive.

But in the supreme irony of our world, it’s also the thing that is killing it. Those thousands of high skilled and high paying jobs are the albatross around coal’s neck. Capitalism has no sense of loyalty or duty. It is the harshest of mistresses, allowing the survival of only the cheapest and most efficient.

Coal is a difficult substance to work with. It can’t be pumped out of the ground and doesn’t transport easily. Coal plants require a lot of people to keep them running, and they wear out quickly, requiring expensive maintenance. I know this well since maintaining these plants is what I did for twenty years.

Coal is slowly being strangled by the economic reality of cheaper wind, cheaper solar but especially cheap and plentiful natural gas produced from fracking. Ironies abound here but few are greater than the fact that with all the work the environmental community has done to fight coal, it’s strongest enemy by far is another fossil fuel with its own serious environmental concerns.

These other methods of generating power are becoming more efficient every year, and continue to improve. They require fewer people with fewer skills, and most of North Dakota’s coal power plants are on the older side of 40 years. The blunt truth is there is only so much that can be done to upgrade an existing power plant, and no one is building new plants… No one will.

The newer industries, including natural gas plants, can be installed in stages. Gone are the days where companies were willing to front the two billion dollars it would take to build a coal plant that wouldn’t become operational for years. All the newer generators are far smaller, cost far less and can be built and brought online much sooner for a better return on investment.

The new generation power plants are also more modular with virtually all the major components being built elsewhere and shipped in. In general, their assembly needs less skill and fewer people. Instead of tens of thousands of complicated welds, these new facilities are mostly bolted together. Furthermore, solar, natural gas and even wind facilities require less maintenance.

Requiring fewer skilled people to build, operate and maintain is a hard formula to beat. The truth is that coal is becoming too expensive to compete exactly because of the high paying jobs it created.

This is something that we all need to be more aware of.

Mark my words, celebrated they may be by some, these closings are going to be disasters for the communities that rely on them. Since the newer industries hire far fewer people for less money, many of these jobs will not be replaced. Towns like Beulah, Hazen and Stanton face becoming Detroits in miniature while thousands of families face a bleak economic future. We are rapidly approaching an ugly cliff.

Right! We know it’s going to happen so what are we doing about it? What is our plan?

Actually, we don’t have one.

And we don’t have one because both sides of the climate change issue are lying to themselves. I know that few want to hear this but it’s true. One side pretends if they remain in power, we can all live in 1975 forever… a 1975 without unions though.

But to make matters worse, many on the liberal/environmental side continue to think that the transition into renewables will be made without much concern thinking that workers can roll over into the new industries at the roughly the same numbers and rates of pay.

Both sides are just fantasies. The climate deniers are blowing smoke up their backsides. The science is sound, the 70’s are gone, and no law, or political party or president will ever turn this around. But understand that for our side to believe that this transition won’t have a significant human cost is just as misguided. Every major industry transition in history has been brutal on the workers, their families and communities. This will be no different.

Trump got elected, in part, by taking advantage of people’s fear of losing their future, and we helped him along by focusing exhaustively on the science and numbers yet ignoring the human element.

We’re the liberals and progressives here. The human element is supposed to be our speciality. It’s what we pride ourselves on.

Let’s not continue to make this mistake.

Recently in:

By Kris Gruberperriex1@gmail.comThat old adage no longer applies: There is now such a thing as a free lunch, and it is here to stay. With help from a willing community, the founders of Lunch Aid North Dakota are continuing their…

By Michael M. Miller  michael.miller@ndsu.eduGermans from Russia Heritage Collection, NDSU Libraries, Fargo,…

Sons of Norway, Kringen Lodge #4-25, is a fraternal organization dedicated to the preservation and promotion of Norwegian culture.Sentrum på 722 2nd Ave N, FargoKringen Kafe er åpen for Kaffe og Bakverk mandag-fredag 9.00 til…

By Sabrina Hornungsabrina@hpr1.comOur opinion: Let our character and characters define usIt’s no secret that North Dakota is one of our nation’s least visited states, in fact I can think of a handful of folks I’ve chatted…

By Ed Raymondfargogadfly@gmail.com A Shock to the Best Congress Money Can Buy: Money Eliminates Poverty! An amazing revelation shocked conservative politicians of both political parties when COVID-19 virtually tanked the U.S.…

To say that this year’s Bartenders Battle was the best display of talent in the six years since its creation would be an understatement and a disservice to not only the bartenders who made it into the competition, but also the…

By Sabrina Hornungsabrina@hpr1.com“If you had talked to me five years ago or even a year ago and told me I was gonna be a chef in Fargo I probably would have looked at you pretty funny. It's wild where food is taking me in…

By Sabrina Hornung  sabrina@hpr1.comAmanda Standalone is a force, in fact one could say she’s an old soul with the Midas touch of…

By Greg Carlsongregcarlson1@gmail.comBefore she introduced us, mutual friend Morgan Davy told me that Anthony Strand had the uncanny ability to remember the exact running time of every movie he had seen. And he has seen a lot of…

By Alicia Underlee Nelson                                                                                                                                                                                                             …

By Kris Gruberperriex1@gmail.comDrag shows, for me, feel like a celebration of artistry, esthetic, music, and camaraderie. With a dash of confetti thrown in.The local drag community is a close-knit family. Giving back to affiliated…

by Kris Gruberperriex1@gmail.comAdam Quesnell's last show at The Cellar beneath the Front Street Taproom in Fargo was in early September of 2018. He was embarking on a seminal move from Minneapolis to LA. As always, his comedy was…

By Kris Gruberperriex1@gmail.comSpring is here (mostly), and our area is buzzing with people eager to get back out and about -- many newly vaccinated and feeling a bit safer. Partnering with Jade Events, Fargo Brewing is just…

by Laurie J Bakeremsdatter@gmail.com Part of modern yoga is participating in the world around us. We live in a time of upheaval in society and nature, and of great suffering in humans of all ages. Most of us perceive this suffering…

By Theresa L. Goodrichsubmit@hpr1.comIt was day ten of our epic southwest road trip and we’d made it to Arizona. After camping in Oklahoma, the Texas Panhandle, and New Mexico, we were exhausted, but fortunately our night in…

by Annie Prafckesubmit@hpr1.com17 June 2021On June 19th, from 12pm to 7pm, nonprofit Faith4Hope Scholarship Fund is hosting their first ever Juneteenth Freedom Celebration at Lindenwood Park in Fargo. It is free and open to the…