Tracker Pixel for Entry

Proposed Carbon Pipeline

News | November 24th, 2022

By Laura Simmons

laurasimmons2025@u.northwestern.edu

Summit Carbon Solutions approached North Dakota land owner Kurt Swensonin August 2021, requesting to lease out Swenson’s land to sequester, or store, carbon dioxide underground in the pore space, which is the part of soil containing liquid and gas about one to two miles underground.

After reviewing the proposed contract with the help of attorneys, Swenson said that no attorney in the state of North Dakota would recommend signing it.

“We live out in the country on land that's been in my wife's family for 112 years now,” Swenson said. “The last thing that we want to do is disrespect those that toiled on the land and struggled over the many, many years to give us the gift of being able to live where we live.”

Swenson said the proposed contract would allow the company to install whatever they wanted on the surface of his land, there was poor insurance and the monetary compensation was low at $25 per acre. Swenson said this is about 200 times less than what the oil or gas industry would pay for similar acreage.

In January 2022, Swenson said he provided Summit with a counter-offer lease, but Summit has not yet provided formal changes to their originally proposed lease. Swenson said he thinks Summit is planning on forcing landowners to give up their pore space, using the 2009 Senate Bill 2139. The bill states that if a company has made a “good-faith effort” to get all landowners' consent and has obtained the consent of at least 60% of the landowners, then the North Dakota Industrial Commission can issue a permit and the non-consenting pore space owners will be “equitably compensated” for their land.

However, Swenson said because carbon sequestration is still fairly new, the market value of pore space has not been determined.

“The law that was written in 2009 that allows them to do this is unconstitutional,” Swenson said. “If Summit were to work with us to negotiate with us and answer and address our concerns, then they're not going to have to find out the hard way that [this law] is unconstitutional in court.”

Summit is planning to construct a 2,000-mile carbon dioxide pipeline through Iowa, Nebraska, South Dakota, Minnesota and North Dakota. The pipeline will capture and compress the carbon dioxide emissions from 32 ethanol plants and then ship it to western North Dakota to be sequestered.

Jesse Harris, Summit’s director of public affairs, said carbon sequestration is critical for the future of ethanol plants as it will open up previously barred markets in California and Canada, which have low carbon fuel standards.

This is important because the ethanol industry contributes $50 billion to the United State’s GDP, provides 400,000 jobs and purchases 40% of U.S.-grown corn, Harris said.

“Capturing 12 million tons of CO2 on an annual basis, that's the equivalent of removing about 2.6 million vehicles off the road every year,” Harris said. “Carbon capture is an important part of how we're going to reach net zero emissions and, from an environmental standpoint, there are clear benefits.”

Chris Boshart, general manager of Corn LP, an Iowa-based ethanol plant, said the partnership with Summit provides the company with a more certain future. He said the coronavirus pandemic, which reduced the usage of many cars, harmed the ethanol industry and the increase in electrical cars is a concern for the future of the ethanol industry.

A more stable future for Corn LP would also affect local farmers, who receive a higher market value for their crops from Corn LP, Boshart said.

“[Our company] was something that a lot of folks got excited about,” Boshart said. “We have local jobs, we're owned by local businesses and a lot of local farmers and we're processing local farmer corn.”

Dakota Resource Council (DRC); a nonprofit environmental advocacy organization; is concerned about Summit’s motives.

DRC Field Organizer Eliot Huggins said Summit’s income is coming from two main sources: the premium price they can put on “clean” energy and the tax credits the company could receive from the government.

The Inflation Reduction Act of 2022 makes the company eligible to receive $85 per ton of sequestered, or underground stored, carbon dioxide. This is up from the previous $50 per metric ton. The project has the capacity to sequester 12 million tons per year, letting the company make billions of dollars in tax credits.

“I don't think this is gonna be a very [long-term] project,” Huggins said. “I think it’s people trying to get rich quick on these tax credits.”

Sam Wagner, DRC Field Organizer, said “This is not a left or right issue. There's people of all stripes that are banding together. People that wouldn’t have had us in the same room with them are talking to us now. And that's a story in itself in North Dakota, how a lot of people are wising up to some of these tactics because it's affecting them directly.”

Eliot Huggins is also concerned about the safety of the pipeline. Carbon dioxide pipelines have a risk of rupturing. If this happens, it will impair the breathing of animals and people nearby because the carbon dioxide, being heavier than oxygen, will push oxygen higher into the atmosphere.

There are no federal regulations governing carbon dioxide pipelines. Following the rupture of a carbon dioxide pipeline in Mississippi in 2020, the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration is working to update regulations.

“We believe [carbon dioxide sequestration] is an untested technology at an untested company on an untested scale that puts rural communities and farmers at risk,” Huggins said.

However, Summit director Jesse Harris is confident in the safety of the technology. He said carbon capture, transportation and sequestration use technologies that have been proven to be safe.

As another line of defense, Harris said the system will be monitored constantly and, if there’s a change in pressure, it will be shut down.

“Safety is our number one priority,” Harris said. “We would not have initiated this project unless we had the highest degree of confidence it will be safe for landowners and communities.”

Summit is currently persuading landowners to sign 99-year easements, allowing the company to install the carbon dioxide pipeline in exchange for money. Harris informed HPR that Summit had crossed a “major milestone” November 8, reaching a majority of signed easement agreements along the proposed pipeline route.

Todd McMichael is one North Dakota landowner refusing to sign an easement agreement with Summit. McMichael said he didn’t sign because the indemnification and compensation portions were terrible. For example, if the carbon pipeline was to rupture and it killed McMichael’s own cattle, then Summit would cover the expenses; but, if the pipeline ruptured and killed his neighbor’s cattle, then Summit wouldn’t cover the damages, according to McMichael who said he should not have to be responsible for the damages caused by the rupture.

McMichael said he has convinced representative Alisa Mitskog, Senator Larry Luick, Representative Cynthia Schreiber-Beck, Senator Mark F. Weber, Representative Kathy Skroch, Representative Jeffery J. Magrum, and Representative Mike Brandenburg that eminent domain should not be used for Summit’s pipeline.

“Pretty much everyone I talked to I changed their mind, but they're all so afraid of Doug Burgum, about him pulling PAC money and stuff away from them that they don't want to challenge him,” McMichael said.

McMichael’s advocacy attracted the attention of Governor Doug Burgum, who approached McMichael after the Fargo National Cemetery Volunteer Committee’s Memorial Day service and tried to change his mind, according to McMichael.

“[Governor Burgum] was giving me all the talking points that Summit Carbon Solution gives, and I don't back down from it because I know I have all the facts, McMichael said. “This has not been a good project from the start.”

McMichael cited three main areas where the project would not be good for North Dakota. One, he said the low-carbon credit fuel market in California is too saturated. In January 2021, the average low carbon fuel credit cost $199 compared to October, 2022 when it was at an average of $106 per credit. Two, McMichael said only one of the 32 Summit ethanol plant partners are in North Dakota. Three, the project will not be taxed for the first 10 years due to N.D. Cent. Code 57-06-17.1. Four, the sequestered carbon cannot be extracted for enhanced oil recovery, according to McMichael.

“We just became a dumping station for 32 ethanol plants with only one in the state of North Dakota,” McMichael said.






Recently in:

By Maddie Robinson  maddierobi.mr@gmail.comIn order to get affordable child care for her son, Paulina Erbele has to drive from her work in Gackle,…

By John Showalter  john.d.showalter@gmail.comphoto by Logan MacraeAnyone who lives in the Fargo-Moorhead area knows that its yearly weather is a sequence of…

Saturday, December 2, 20231st seating: 3:30pm, 2nd seating: 6pmSons of Norway, 722 2nd Ave N, FargoCelebrate the holidays with a four-course plated sit-down dinner and hosted by the one and only Frode Tilden. “If you love…

By Sabrina Hornungsabrina@hpr1.comRemember the legacy of the NPL.Last Saturday I had the opportunity to attend the annual meeting and dinner hosted by the Dakota Resource Council in Bismarck. I came in feeling a little defeated,…

By Ed Raymondfargogadfly@gmail.comHow Many of Napoleon’s Hats Will Save Planet Earth for Homo Sapiens?Before I get into this week’s subject of why we need to double the number of college majors in English and Humanities if we…

We are looking for 55-gallon plastic food grade barrels, do you have ideas or connections?We use these barrels to teach our resilient yard workshop series including Make Your Own Rain Barrel and Make Your Own Compost Tumbler. If…

By Rick Gionrickgion@gmail.comThe temperatures have dropped and so have the leaves in the Upper Midwest. That means it's now the holiday season. Part of the joy of this special season for me is eating. But first things first.…

Dropkick Murphys Put Music to the Words of Woody GuthrieBy Sabrina Hornungsabrina@hpr1.comPhoto by Dave StaubleWith the release of 2022’s “This Machine Still Kills Fascists” and 2023’s “Okemah Rising.” The Dropkick…

By Greg Carlsongregcarlson1@gmail.com“Saltburn,” the highly anticipated follow-up to “Promising Young Woman” – which earned Oscar gold for Best Original Screenplay – doesn’t quite equal the bite and sting of…

By Sabrina Hornungsabrina@hpr1.comA trio of Burleigh County artists are making their mark in Wing, North Dakota, to promote local foods and are quite literally painting the town, or at least the newly acquired Wing City Government…

By Eric Dallmanericd@hpr1.comWe recently watched “The PROM” at Chanhassen Dinner Theatre, and it was an experience that left a lasting impact on us. The story, a heartwarming yet familiar one, follows a group of Broadway stars…

By Annie Prafckeannieprafcke@gmail.com AUSTIN, Texas – As a Chinese-American, connecting to my culture through food is essential, and no dish brings me back to my mother’s kitchen quite like hotdish. Yes, you heard me right –…

By Sabrina Hornungsabrina@hpr1.comNew Jamestown Brewery Serves up Local FlavorThere’s something delicious brewing out here on the prairie and it just so happens to be the newest brewery west of the Red River and east of the…

By John Showalter  john.d.showalter@gmail.comThey sell fentanyl test strips and kits to harm-reduction organizations and…

JANUARY 19, 1967– MARCH 8, 2023 Brittney Leigh Goodman, 56, of Fargo, N.D., passed away unexpectedly at her home on March 8, 2023. Brittney was born January 19, 1967, to Ruth Wilson Pollock and Donald Ray Goodman, in Hardinsburg,…

By Faye Seidlerfayeseidler@gmail.com On the first day of the month I ask people to thank a journalist they know or someone who contributes to papers in some meaningful way. When I grew up, my best friend's father was a journalist…