Tracker Pixel for Entry

Two bills fight to define ND ethics

by C.S. Hagen | .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address) | News | February 15th, 2019

Dark Money movie playing at the Fargo Theater - North Dakotans for Public Integrity's Facebook page

BISMARCK – Two bills are fighting for ethical supremacy in the North Dakota State Legislature.

Senate Bill 2148, sponsored by Senator Tim Mathern, a Democrat from Fargo, received a ‘Do Pass’ from Special Ethics Committee on Monday. The bill, if passed, will establish the creation of an ethics commission in North Dakota, enforce regulations on naming sole contributors for political contributions over $200, impose fines on violations, and adopt rules passed by popular vote pertaining to Measure 1, or article XIV of the Constitution of North Dakota.

The competing bill, House Bill 1521, sponsored by Republican Representative Chet Pollert and Senator Rich Wardner, is expected to pass in the House of Representatives. Among other changes the bill takes out the word “solely” for being responsible to report political donations.

Since the North Dakota Legislature convened, drafts of both bills have had hearings in the two chambers of government.

One of the main issues of contention between the competing bills comes down to one word: “solely.” The issue stems from the definitions of reporting where campaign funds come from.

Mathern’s bill definition: “‘Ultimate and true source’ means the person who knowingly contributed over two hundred dollars, adjusted for inflation, to influence a statewide election or an election for the legislative assembly.”

Pollert’s proposed change to HB 1521 would add the word solely: “‘Ultimate and true source’ means the person who knowingly contributed over two hundred dollars, adjusted for inflation, solely to influence a statewide election or an election for the legislative assembly.”

The change is more than semantics, Ellen Chaffee, one of the founders of North Dakotans for Public Integrity, who helped head up the 2018 fight for Measure 1, now known as Article XIV. The Constitutional measure will become law after one of the bills pass both houses and is signed by Governor Doug Burgum.

“If the Senate passes 2148 on the floor, then it will go to the House and we will have some leverage to make the final outcome at least a little more sensible,” Chaffee said. “House Bill 1521 is wildly unconstitutional. Anyone who believes in Constitutional law, or thinks legislators should listen to the people, or thinks ego-driven lawsuits are a waste of taxpayer money should be outraged by their behavior, no matter what they think of Article XIV.”

Gregory Stites, an attorney who is working with those involved in writing SB 2148, said Pollert’s proposed changes is full of loopholes.

“Even a PAC donation where a person is told $1 of your donation goes to overhead and $999 goes to influence isn’t reportable because the person’s $1,000 contribution isn’t going ‘solely’ to influence,” Stites said in an email.

Pollert’s House Bill proposal also raised penalties for false reporting from $100 to $500, and wants to classify such infractions as class B misdemeanors.

“Clearly, SB 2148 is vastly superior to the House Bill,” Stites said.

Complainants, which are typically protected in other state ethics commissions or committees, is one of primary issues opponents of establishing an Ethics Commission have. They believe rampant complaints will lead to widespread public knowledge and defamation.

The proposed bill given the go ahead by the Special Ethics Committee states that a complainant must make a signed statement swearing to authenticity within five days and if the deadline is missed, the commission will not investigate the complaint.

Reckless complaints will also be classified as defamation, and the North Dakota Secretary of State’s office can impose a fine of $100 upon anyone who commits a violation, according to SB 2148.

All complaints are deemed confidential and will not be made public until after six months, when an investigator has finished an investigation and the Ethics Commission issues a written report of findings. The Ethics Commission also does not have the power to terminate the employment of a public official.

Mathern's bill will allow the future Ethics Commission to determine a monetary amount for gifts that do not need to be reported.

A person does not have to file a report with the North Dakota Secretary of State’s office if a gift is to or from a family member, if the gift is for informational material, advice, or education, reimbursement for travel or meals during a conference, or while advising, or a good or service that doesn’t raise ethical concerns under rules established by the Ethics Commission.

Mathern’s proposed bill will be heard in the state Senate this week.

“What we need,” Ellen Chaffee said, “is pressure on the Senators to pass SB 2148 this week. That’s crucial.”

North Dakotans for Public Integrity at the State Capitol Building - North Dakotans for Public Integrity's Facebook page

Recently in:

FARGO – The city is requesting help from the public to produce one million sandbags in preparation for the 2019 Spring Flood. There remains a 10 percent chance waters will rise up to 40.3 feet, higher than the flood of 2009. Two…

By Gabrielle Herschgabbyhersch@gmail.com“North Dakota (and Minnesota) nice” is an attitude, a stereotype, and a way of life that has permeated our region, as well as perceptions of the Midwest, since as long as people have been…

Friday, March 22, 6-8 p.m.Red Raven Espresso Parlor, 916 Main Ave, FargoDigital photos from North Dakota’s backroads. Hornung has been exploring the roads less traveled for close to a decade. Carefully documenting and collecting…

“North Dakota Nice,” is a phrase that I see getting tossed around more and more these days. Many are sincere and others display yet another facet of our disposition that’s not nearly as desirable. Yes, we’re professin’…

The Battle Between Extreme Capitalism And Democratic SocialismAfter Vice-President Mike Pence representing racial and extreme capitalism ended his scathing rant about democratic socialism at the Conservative Political Action…

The eighth week of this year’s HPR Cocktail Showdown was another tripleheader for our panel of judges. On this particular week, we found ourselves focused on a trio of downtown dining and entertainment establishments to visit…

In rural Minnesota, outside of Park Rapids, Amy Thielen was attempting to light her wood-fired oven. It is in her brand-new kitchen that she hopes to teach cooking classes out of, which is a far cry from what it was when she and…

The Fargo-Moorhead Symphony Orchestra has had its fair share of guest performances headlining its concerts over the years. They all have impressive resumes, their fair share of awards, and worldwide recognition. However, bringing…

FARGO – Most people know the Trail of Tears that followed the Indian Removal Act of 1830. The U.S. government – under the direction of President Andrew Jackson – forcibly removed tens of thousands of Natives from their…

Hidden away in the tiny North Dakota town of Lefor I find Karen Valley, an author and an artist. She is without a doubt the artist’s artist. Her soul is art, talent and words. Meeting her is a true experience in finding a soul so…

To many people unfamiliar with the wide range of the musical genre, the word ‘opera’ conjures up stereotypical images of people in period costumes and large women in Viking garb singing in foreign languages. The truth, however,…

Stand-up comedy is traditionally a one-way exchange. Outside of the odd question addressed to a random audience member, the limit of the spectators’ contribution to the conversation is their laughter at the comedy stylings being…

By Gabrielle Herschgabbyhersch@gmail.comThink & Drink is coming to Fargo! Organized by Humanities North Dakota, Think & Drink is a happy hour series that hosts a facilitated public conversation about big issues and ideas. Lead by a…

I’m a big man, I’m tall and powerful, but this also causes some issues in the body department. I suffer from acute scoliosis in my lower back, and pain radiates from this area on a daily basis. I have only ever had one massage…

by Devin Joubertdevinlillianjoubert@gmail.comIt’s that beautiful time of the year that’s filled with seasonal decorations, sparkly lights, warm family gatherings, and delicious feasts. I love everything about this time of the…

I’ve got a problem. I need to write a column that is going to be kind of critical of three people I like, and I’m trying to figure out how to do it without making them all angry at me. Their names are Sara, Doug and Marvin.…