Tracker Pixel for Entry

​Whose Local Breakfast Reigns Supreme?

All About Food | February 23rd, 2022

By Rick Gion

rickgion@gmail.com

It’s the Packers vs. Spartans breakfast battle of two locally established heavyweights. You guessed it: I’m talking about West Fargo’s Deaner’s Diner and North Fargo’s The Shack on Broadway. This is a serious competition so let’s get ready to rumble.

In this debut column, I’ll be comparing just breakfast items: meaty omelets, hashbrowns and pancakes. In a different bout, I’ll maybe do a review of hot beef sandwiches at the two establishments. A hot turkey sandwich round in that competition might also have to take place to cover the whole squared circle.

I’ll be honest about my bias. I’ve been a fan of The Shack since high school. I grew up a north sider and lived about a mile from the breakfast icon. That means I’ve been eating there for over 20 years. There’s a reason why The Shack consistently wins best breakfast in local media competitions. It never disappoints. Never.

But, the battle isn’t over quite yet. I’ve been enjoying the homemade pie at Deaner’s before it was Deaner’s. Back in the day, it was TNT’s Diner. TNT’s was solid, but I think Deaner’s is at a different level these days and that’s a good thing. It’s why Deaner’s gets recognition on the internet by plenty of foodie websites as one of North Dakota’s best diners. The place is legendary.

Since The Shack won the High Plains Reader’s “Best Bets” for the Fargo-Moorhead area’s top breakfast last year, let’s review Deaner’s first to give them the first shot.

At Deaner’s, I ordered the “meat lovers” omelet, two pancakes and orange juice. The pancakes did not come as a side for the meal so I had to order them separately. I ordered two, and they were huge - like face-covering huge. The omelet had bacon, ham, sausage and a melted cheese blend. Hashbrowns came with the meal, and they were nice and crispy. Toast was also included. All in all, this breakfast was superb, and the service was excellent.

Here are downsides to Deaner’s: It’s a drive for me from downtown Fargo, and the pancakes didn’t come with the meal.

At The Shack, I ordered the “meat lovers omelet” and orange juice. The pancakes were part of the meal so I didn’t have to pay extra for them. The omelet had bacon, ham, sausage and a melted cheese blend. Hashbrowns came with the meal, and they were nice and crispy. Toast was not included.

By the way, The Shack’s pancakes are the best in the area in my opinion. I’m guessing they use malted milk powder in the batter. That’s probably what gives them a little twang. I apologize to The Shack if I just gave away their secret ingredient!

Here are downsides to The Shack: The weekend brunch wait, and it’s also a bit of a drive for me from downtown.

Omelet plates at both establishments were about $11. However, my tab at Deaner’s was a bit more due to the addition of pancakes.

Paying a fitting homage to these local breakfast giants is tough. And, there wasn’t a knockout to end this match. It was extremely close. For the ‘most important meal of the day,’ The Shack gets the heavyweight belt by only a few points. However, that doesn’t mean there aren’t items at Deaner’s that may be better. It’s worth going back there to try other Midwestern lunch or dinner fare.

The next bout in this local breakfast challenge is a comparison of Fryn’ Pan vs. Randy’s on University. Bring it on!

____________________

Rick Gion administers a Facebook group page called “Fargo-Moorhead Eats” that’s dedicated to the area’s great cooks and cuisine. Check it out, join, and feel free to post items about your local culinary adventures and home cooking.

YOU SHOULD KNOW

The Shack on Broadway at 3215 N Broadway in Fargo

Deaner’s Diner at 405 Main Ave W in West Fargo








Recently in:

By Olivia Slyteroslyter.g@cord.eduPhotos by Sabrina HornungFor months, the Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS) has been asking the heavy question “Should the 1973 ruling of Roe v. Wade be overturned?” On May 2nd,…

Selected Summer EventsJuneJune 21 – Primitive Man 10 Year Anniversary Tour – The Aquarium, Fargo, NDJune 22-27 – Don’t Hug Me Musical – Stage West - POW/MIA Plaza, West Fargo, NDJune 22 – Ryan Necci and The Buffalo…

Monday, July 4, all dayUlland Park2401 47th Avenue Southhttps://www.gfsertoma.org/4th-of-july-celebrationGrand Forks hosts the biggest Independence Day bash in the region–and it’s an all-day affair. Come early for yard games, a…

By John Strand and Thomas Bixbyjas@hpr1.comOur Opinion: Are Many of Us ‘Detached From Reality?’Why is it that many Americans believe the falsehood that Joe Biden’s election to the Presidency was a fraud, that it was rigged?In…

By Ed Raymondfargogadfly@gmail.com Christianity Has Fallen Off the CrossCorky and I have classified ourselves as faithful Christians for nearly ninety years, but we both have reached the point where a solid majority of…

Well shiver me timbers. After weeks of sampling some of the finest drinks in F-M from more bars than we could shake a belaying pin at, the results of High Plains Reader’s 6th Annual Cocktail Showdown are in! For nine weeks,…

By Rick Gionrickgion@gmail.comPhotos by Rick GionSome people say that a pizza tastes better if you cut it in squares. And, the main event in this food battle features Fargo-Moorhead’s favorite thin-crust squared circles.Judging a…

By Martin Beckman and Jordan TepleyHigh Plains Reader: Just to fill in the people that are unfamiliar. Who are y'all and could you tell us a little about Suffering Hour?Kenn Nardi: Suffering Hour is a black/death metal band based…

By Greg Carlsongregcarlson1@gmail.comWhile some Josephine Decker fans have decided to turn up their noses at her adaptation of Jandy Nelson’s 2010 YA novel “The Sky Is Everywhere,” I was delighted by the filmmaker’s…

By Sabrina Hornungsabrina@hpr1.comArtwork: Woodcut by Danielle Gravon titled "Allegory of Fargo Winter I"On June 18, the Rourke will be holding their 62nd annual Midwestern Preview, the date celebrating the opening anniversary of…

By Brittney Goodman  goodmanbritg@gmail.comJuneJune 16 – 17 - Footloose presented by Thompson Theater – Empire Arts Center –…

By Sabrina Hornungsabrina@hpr1.comCharlie Berens is a man of many hats. The creator of the “Manitowoc Minute” is a newsman, comedian, writer and musician. We had the opportunity to speak with the Wisconsin native about his new…

By Kris Gruberperriex1@gmail.comSpring is here (mostly), and our area is buzzing with people eager to get back out and about -- many newly vaccinated and feeling a bit safer. Partnering with Jade Events, Fargo Brewing is just…

by Laurie J Bakeremsdatter@gmail.com Part of modern yoga is participating in the world around us. We live in a time of upheaval in society and nature, and of great suffering in humans of all ages. Most of us perceive this suffering…

By Sabrina Hornungsabrina@hpr1.comLehr Mayor and Council Members Donate City Salaries To Save Legion HallEvery rural community has at least one social space that holds multiple generations of memories and has remained a social…

By Madeline Lukemadelineluke@ymail.comSonja Kaye, of CLEAN in Fargo gave the third of four talks on climate change issues specific to North Dakota for the “What in the World Series,” in Valley City on April 5. While the topic…